Kindly share you feedback about the website – Click here
[Time Allowed: 3 Hours] [Maximum Marks: 80]General Instructions:
(i) This question paper contains 34 questions.
(ii) Marks are indicated against each question.
(iii) Answers should be brief and to the point.
(iv) Answers to the questions carrying 3 marks may be from 50 to 75 words.
(v) Answers to the questions carrying 4 marks may be about 150 words.
(vi) Answers to the questions carrying 6 marks may be about 200 words.
(vii) Attempt all parts of the questions together.
1. Read the following Statements-Assertion (A) and Reason (R), and choose one of the correct alternatives given below:
Assertion (A): The principles of management are yet to be evolved.
Reason (R): Principles of Management are said to be evolutionary in nature as these principles have evolved over a long period of time with continuous practice and experimentation. Alternatives:
(a) Both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true and Reason (R) is the correct explanation of Assertion (A)
(b) Both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true but Reason (R) is not the correct explanation of Assertion (A)
(c) Assertion (A) is true but Reason (R) is false
(d) Assertion (A) is false but Reason (R) is true
View AnswerAns. (d) Assertion (A) is false but Reason (R) is true
2. Read the following statements carefully.
Statement I: Encoding is the process of converting a message into communication symbols such as words, pictures, gestures etc. by the sender for transmission.
Statement II: Decoding is the process of converting encoded symbols of the sender.
Choose the correct option from the options given below:
(a) Statement I is true and II is false
(b) Statement II is true and I is false
(c) Both the statements are true
(d) Both the statements are false
View AnswerAns. (c) Both the statements are true
3. Hemant bought a packet of chips from a local shopkeeper and found that the ingredients given on the label were not legible. He complained about it to the company. The company sent a written apology stating that they will make sure that existing packets are withdrawn from the market and new packets with legible labels are soon made available.
Which consumer right is being exercised by Hemant?
(a) Right to choose
(b) Right to be heard
(c) Right to safety
(d) None of these
View AnswerAns. (b) Right to be heard
4. Match the marketing philosophies in Column I with their main focus in Column II.
Column I | Column II |
A. Product concept | (i) Production on a large scale |
B. Production concept | (ii) Enhancing quality of product |
C. Marketing concept | (iii) Customer satisfaction |
(a) A-(i), B(ii), C(iii)
(b) A-(iii), B(ii), C(i)
(c) A-(ii), B(iii), C(i)
(d) A-(ii), B(i), C(iii)
View AnswerAns. (d) A-(ii), B(i), C(iii)
5. __________ is a factor affecting the capital structure of a company.
(a) Cash flow position
(b) Flexibility
(c) Control consideration
(d) All of these
View AnswerAns. (d) All of these
6. Identify the responsibility of consumers being highlighted in the picture given below.

(a) Be aware about various goods and services available in the market so that an intelligent and wise choice can be made.
(b) Buy only standardised goods as they provide quality assurance. Thus, look for ISI mark on electrical goods, FPO mark on food products, Hallmark on jewellery, etc.
(c) Learn about the risks associated with products and services, follow manufacturer’s instructions and use the products safely.
(d) Ask for a cash memo on purchase of goods or services.
View AnswerAns. (d) Ask for a cash memo on purchase of goods or services.
7. Which of the following is the primary aim of financial management?
(a) Optimum utilisation of resources
(b) Link present with future
(c) Ensures availability of funds wherever required
(d) Wealth maximization
Ans. (d) Wealth maximisation
8. The management of an electronics firm suspected that their two employees were robbing it. It hired investigators who advised the firm to install a software program that could secretly log every single stroke of the suspects computer keys and send an encrypted e-mail report back to them. Investigators revealed that the two employees were deleting orders from the corporate books after processing them and pocketing the revenues. The programme picked up on their plans to steal a large shipment of goods late one night. When the suspects entered, they were arrested and charged with embezzlement.
State the importance of the function of ‘Controlling’ highlighted in the above case.
(a) Controlling ensures order and discipline.
(b) Controlling improves employees’ morale.
(c) Controlling judges accuracy of standards.
(d) Controlling accomplishes organisational goals.
View AnswerAns. (a) Controlling ensures order and discipline.
9. On the introduction of ‘Goods and Services Tax Act’, experts in the field of business started analysing and forecasting its impact on various sectors and industries. Vivek, an established businessman, attended a few seminars and conferences organized by such experts to familiarize himself with this information. He wanted to use these forecasts to reduce the uncertainty in making decisions for the future in his business.
Name the step in the planning process that is being discussed in the above paragraph.
(a) Follow up action
(b) Selection of alternative
(c) Setting objectives.
(d) Developing premises.
View AnswerAns. (d) Developing premises.
10. The forces relating to scientific improvements and innovations which provide new ways, methods and techniques of producing goods and services and operating a business is:
(a) Social environment
(b) Technological environment
(c) Internal environment
(d) Micro environment
View AnswerAns. (b) Technological environment
11. Arrange the following steps in the process of controlling in the correct sequence:
(i) Measurement of Actual Performance
(ii) Analysing Deviations
(iii) Comparing Actual Performance with Standards
(iv) Setting Performance Standards
Choose the correct option:
(a) (i), (ii), (iv), (iii)
(b) (iii), (ii), (i), (iv)
(c) (iv), (i), (iii), (ii)
(d) (ii), (iii), (i), (iv)
View AnswerAns. (c) (iv), (i), (iii), (ii)
12. The managers at ____________ level of management are responsible for the welfare and survival of an organisation.
(a) Top
(b) Middle
(c) Lower
(d) All of these
View AnswerAns. (a) Top
13. The requirement of working capital will be more for a business concern manufacturing:
(a) Bread
(b) Coolers
(c) Both (a) and (b)
(d) Neither (a) nor (b)
View AnswerAns. (b) Coolers
14. Choose the function of management responsible for motivating employees and giving instructing to them to perform the tasks assigned to them.
(a) Planning
(b) Staffing
(c) Directing
(d) Controlling
View AnswerAns. (c) Directing
15. Mansi saw ‘Buy one get one free’ printed on the label of the package of a mosquito repellant. The function which labelling is performing here is:
(a) Gives information to consumer
(b) Describes the product and specifies its content
(c) Promotes the product
(d) All of these
View AnswerAns. (c) Promotes the product
16. The functions of management complementary to each other are:
(a) Planning and Organising
(b) Organising and Staffing
(c) Controlling and Planning
(d) Directing and Controlling
View AnswerAns. (c) Controlling and Planning
17. Read the following statements carefully.
Statement I: Accountability can be delegated.
Statement II: Responsibility can be delegated completely.
Choose the correct option from the options given below:
(a) Statement I is true and II is false
(b) Statement II is true and I is false
(c) Both the statements are true
(d) Both the statements are false
View AnswerAns. (d) Both the statements are false
18. A company dealing in apparels has decided to clear its stock. It has a huge pile of unsold stock in all its branches across the country. It has decided to give discount on its products. It even has decided to go for various fashion shows in different colleges. They also have decided to sponsor a few events.
Identify the marketing management philosophy highlighted above.
(a) Marketing concept
(b) Selling concept
(c) Production concept
(d) Product concept
View AnswerAns. (b) Selling concept
19. Which of the following is a factor affecting dividend decision?
(a) Cash flow position
(b) Stability of earnings
(c) Contractual constraints
(d) All of these
View AnswerAns. (d) All of these
20. Which type of recruitment gives the management a wider choice while selecting the people for employment?
(a) External recruitment
(b) Internal recruitment
(c) Recruitment through labour contractor
(d) None of these
View AnswerAns. (a) External recruitment
21. Differentiate between Functional and Divisional Structure on the basis of:
(a) Formation (b) Responsibility (c) Cost involved
Basis | Functional Structure | Divisional Structure |
(a) Formation | It is formed on the basis of functions or activities performed | It is formed on the basis of product lines or area of operation. |
(b) Responsibility | It is difficult to fix responsibility for success or failure of a product. | It is easy to fix responsibility for the performance. |
(c) Cost involved | It is economical as functions are not duplicated. | It is costly as there is duplication of resources and functions in departments |
Or
State the meaning of essential elements of delegation.
View AnswerAns. The three elements of delegation are:
(a) Authority: It is the right to command and to take decisions. Authority originates by the virtue of an individual’s position. The higher the level of management, more is the authority. It flows downwards from a superior to his subordinate.
(b) Responsibility: It is the obligation of a subordinate to properly perform the assigned work. Responsibility flows upwards, i.e., a subordinate is responsible for the duty assigned to him by his superior.
(c) Accountability: It means answerability for the final outcome. Once authority has been delegated and responsibility is entrusted, one cannot deny accountability. This is to ensure that the duties are properly discharged by the subordinates. It flows upwards from a subordinate to his superior.
22. Samta Ltd. is in need of finance to expand the business. The finance manager, Sumit, is looking into different sources of funds available. After doing the cost and risk analysis, he found debt as the best option but as the company has to pay huge insurance premium for the plant and machinery and lease for the building, the decision was taken to raise funds through equity. Identify and explain the factor which affected this decision.
View AnswerAns. The factor which affected the financing decision of Samta Ltd. is fixed operating costs.
Fixed operating costs: Debt financing increases fixed operating cost of the concern, namely interest. Hence if a business has high fixed operating cost in the form of building rent, insurance premium, salaries, etc., then lower debt financing is better. If fixed operating cost is less, then debt financing can be preferred.
23. How does management help in the development of society?
View AnswerAns. Management helps in fulfilling the multiple objectives towards different groups who constituted the organisation. In this process, management helps in the development of organisation and the society. It helps by providing good quality products and services, creating employment opportunities, adopting new technology for advancement and leads the path towards growth and development.
Or
Identify the type of dimensions of environment in the following cases:
(a) It includes factors like money supply, price level, monetary policy etc.
(b) Increased awareness towards health has increased demand for organic food.
(c) A stable government builds up confidence among the firms to invest in big projects.
View AnswerAns. (a) Economic Environment
(b) Social Environment
(c) Political Environment
24. Dominos offered ‘Vrat Special Menu’ during Navratras to attract the Indian customers with vegetarian pizza made of water-chestnut flour (singhada atta), and white millet flour (Samak ke chawal ka atta). It was topped with fresh mozzarella cheese with rock salt, tomatoes, paneer and crunchy sabudana. The tomato sauce was made without onions and garlic and used rock salt rather than common salt. State and explain the feature of management which is highlighted in the above case.
View AnswerAns. The feature of management highlighted here is ‘Management is a dynamic function’.
Management is a dynamic function: An organisation is affected by its environment. Management has to keep an eye on the changes in the environment and make necessary changes in itself and its goal according to the needs of the environment and to adapt itself. This makes the management dynamic in nature.
25. How can the company satisfy social and esteem needs of its employees?
View AnswerAns. The social and esteem needs of the employees can be satisfied by giving non-financial incentives to them. Thus, company can provide the following incentives to its employees:
(a) Status: It refers to rank or position in the organisation. Social and esteem need, is satisfied through it, as more authority, responsibility and recognition given to employee.
(b) Employee participation: It means involving employees in decision making of the issue related to them. The company work in the form of joint management committees, work committees etc.
(c) Organisational climate: These are the distinguishing characteristics which describe an organisation. These characteristics like individual autonomy, reward orientation, consideration to employees, risk taking etc. influence the behaviour of the individuals in the organisation.
(d) Career advancement opportunity: An opportunity given to an individual to improve his skills and be promoted to the higher level jobs is also an incentive for an employee. Appropriate skill development programmes, workshops and proper training and development programmes help an employee to get promotions.
26. Amit Sports Ltd. was in the business of manufacturing treadmills and had a monopoly in the market. The business was doing very well and the company was consistently able to meet its objective of 20% increase in sales year after year. Encouraged by the good track record, Mr. Akhil, the Managing Director of the company, kept an ambitious target of 30% increase in sales for the next year. The same year, two competitors entered the market and the company could not achieve its targets. Identify and explain the limitations of one of the functions of management because of which the company was not able to meet its targets.
View AnswerAns. The company could not achieve the targeted objective due to the limitations of planning which are as follows:
(a) Leads to rigidity: The existence of a plan puts managerial activities in a rigid framework. Programmes are carried out according to the plan and deviations are considered to be highly undesirable. This attitude makes managers and employees inflexible in their operation. They become more concerned with observance of rules and procedures as laid down in the plan rather than achieving the goals.
(b) Reduces creativity: People in the organisation just implement the plans made by top management. They blindly implement the orders which results in loss of initiative and interest in them. Thus, planning reduces creativity as there is nothing new or innovative.
(c) May not work in a dynamic environment: The organisation has to continuously adapt itself to the changing environment. Any unforeseen change in the business environment upsets the whole planning.
(d) Time consuming: It is a time consuming process and is not practicable during emergency or crisis. It requires a lot of time to collect information, its analysis and interpretation before preparing plans. Sometimes not much time is left for implementation of plans.
27. Few years ago, there were many malpractices and unfair trading practices like price rigging, unofficial premium on new shares etc. All these had eroded investors’ confidence and multiplied their grievances. To overcome these, Government of India decided to set up a separate regulatory body for this purpose.
(a) Name the separate body set up by the Government of India.
(b) List its three regulatory functions.
View AnswerAns. (a) Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI)
(b) The regulatory functions of Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) are:
(i) It registers brokers, sub-brokers and other players in the market.
(ii) It registers the collective investment schemes and mutual funds.
(iii) It regulates stock brokers, portfolio exchanges, underwriters, merchant bankers and business in stock market and other securities market.
(iv) It regulates the takeover bids of companies.
(v) It undertakes inspections, enquiries and audits of stock exchange and intermediaries.
(vi) Levying fee or other charges for carrying out the purposes of the Act.
28. “If you try to control everything, you may end up in controlling nothing.” Comment.
View AnswerAns. Yes, while controlling, following two principles should be kept in mind, i.e., Critical point control and Management by exception.
Critical point control states that a manager should focus his control on the key result areas which are critical to the success of an organisation. These KRAS are the critical points on which the entire organisation survives, and so the manager should keep his focus on these points while controlling. For example, in a company an increase of 7% in the production cost is more critical, than a 17% increase in its courier cost.
Management by exception is based on the belief that an attempt to control everything results in controlling nothing. Thus, only the significant deviations which go beyond the permissible limit should be brought into the notice of the management and should receive immediate action of management on a priority basis. This saves the time and efforts of managers and focuses managerial attention on important areas. For example, if a plan lays down that defects upto 0.01% are acceptable in the manufacturing unit, then only increase in the defects beyond the 0.01% will be brought to the notice of the management.
Or
How does controlling simplify the task of a manager?
View AnswerAns. Controlling involves verifying whether activities undertaken are in conformity with the plans adopted, instructions issued and results expected. In other words, it is through control that managers/ supervisors ensure the execution of plans and achievement of goals. Controlling simplifies the task of a supervisor by comparing the actual performance with the standards continuously, and finding out the deviations so that the root cause can be identified and not repeated in future.
29. Which process prepares a blue print of an organizations future preparations relating to finance? Give any three reasons why this process is needed?
View AnswerAns. The process of ‘financial planning’ prepares a blue print of an organization’s future preparations relating to finance. The process estimates the funds requirement of a business and specify the source of funds. It is needed because of the following reasons:
(a) Helps in avoiding business shocks and surprises and help the company in preparing for the future.
(b) Helps in coordinating various business functions.
(c) Reduce waste, duplication of efforts and gap in planning.
30. Mr. Kapoor bought a perfume from a Departmental Store and took the cash memo of 500 which he had paid to them. Later on, he found that the MRP of the perfume was 400 only, but the shopkeeper had put a sticker of 500 on the original price.
(a) Do you think that the consumer right is violated here? If yes, then name the right and explain it.
View AnswerAns. Yes, the consumer right violated here is ‘right to be informed’. Consumers have the right to be informed about the quality, quantity, purity, standard and price of goods or services, so as to make the right decision and protect themselves against abusive practices. As per the laws prevalent in India, the manufacturers have to provide information about the products on its package or label.
(b) State any two responsibilities of a consumer other than the one referred here.
View AnswerAns. The two responsibilities of a consumer are:
(i) A consumer must file a complaint in an appropriate consumer forum in case of any inadequacy in the quality of goods purchased or services availed.
(ii) A consumer must be honest in his dealings. He must purchase only legal goods and services so that unscrupulous practices like black marketing, hoarding etc. can be discouraged.
Or
You have been appointed as a Brand Manager of Ford Motors. The Company is to introduce a compact small car in the Indian Market. The name of the car is yet to be decided. You have been asked to chair a brainstorming session. Before the suggestions come forward, you have to briefly explain the participants as to what constitutes a good brand name with the help of suitable examples.
View AnswerAns. The constituents of a good brand name are:
(a) It should be short and simple. Long and complex words should be avoided because they create difficulty in reading and remembering. For instance Lux, Dettol or Surf are short and simple words, which are read and remembered without much effort.
(b) Suggestive brand names are better because they can convey product attributes or benefits. For instance, Hajmola suggests digestive properties, Ujjala suggests brightness, Color soft hair dye from Godrej suggests softness.
(c) It should be distinctive. A brand is distinctive when it stands apart from others in the category. Airtel, Tide, Shell, Cinthol, Perk are still distinctive brand names.
(d) Finally, a brand name should be selected after considering its meaning in other languages and cultures. Some words are perfect in one culture or country but many words become offensive, obscene and inappropriate in other countries.
31. (a) Explain any two leadership styles from the following:

(i) Autocratic style of leadership
View AnswerAns. Authoritative Leadership (Autocratic): It is also known as autocratic leadership. It provides clear expectations for what needs to be done, when it should be done and how it should be done. There is also a clear division between the leader and the followers. Authoritarian leaders make decisions independently with little or no input from the rest of the group. Authoritarian leadership is best applied to situations where there is little time for group decision making or where the leader is the most knowledgeable member of the group.
(ii) Democratic style of leadership
Ans. Democratic Leadership (Participative): It is also known as participative leadership. It is the most effective leadership style. Democratic leaders offer guidance to group members, but they also participate in the group and allow input from other group members. Participative leaders encourage group members to participate, but retain the final say over the decision-making process. Group members feel engaged in the process and are more motivated and creative.
(iii) Laissez-faire style of leadership
Ans. Laissez-faire leadership is also called free-rein leadership. In this, authority is decentralised and the subordinates can take decisions themselves. The leader does not interfere in the activities of the subordinates. He neither leads nor avoids the power. The leader only works as a contact person with the outsiders. He brings in the needed resources and information by subordinates so that group goals can be achieved. Thus, this leadership is centered around the subordinates.
(b) Distinguish between formal communication and informal communication on any three basis.
View AnswerAns.
Basis | Formal Communication | Informal Communication |
(i) Meaning | The communication that flows through channels designed in the organisational chart is known as formal communication. | The communication that takes place without following the formal lines of communication is known as informal communication. |
(ii) Flow of information | It can flow only through pre-defined channels | It can flow freely in any direction. |
(iii) Reliability | It is more reliable | It is less reliable |
(iv) Speed | Information flows at a slower speed | Information flows at a faster speed due to better understanding. |
32. Read the statements given in point 1 and 2, and answer the questions that follow:
1. It is a philosophy that implies selective dispersal of authority because it propagates the belief that people are competent and resourceful. However, it should be applied with caution.
(a) Identify the concept of Organising being discussed above.
View AnswerAns. The concept of Organising being discussed here is “Decentralisation”.
(b) When does an organisation feel the need to embrace this concept?
View AnswerAns. An organisation feels the need to embrace it when it grows in size or complexity.
(c) Why is caution necessary for it to be applied?
View AnswerAns. Caution is necessary when it is applied as it can lead to the organisational disintegration if the departments start to operate on their own guidelines which may be contrary to the interests of the organisation.
2. This type of organisation emerges spontaneously and is not deliberately created by the management.
(a) Identify the type of organisation being discussed above.
View AnswerAns. The type of organisation being discussed here is “Informal organisation”.
(b) How does it help in the achievement of organisational goals?
View AnswerAns. It helps in the achievement of organisational goals by compensating for inadequacies in the formal organisation.
(c) How does it help its members?
View AnswerAns. It helps to fulfil the social needs of the members and allows them to find like-minded people. It gives them a sense of belongingness in the organisation.
33. Pricing of a product is an important and effective competitive weapon in marketing which depends upon various factors.’ Explain any four such factors.
View AnswerAns. The factors that affect the pricing of a product or service are:
(a) Product cost: The cost of producing, distributing and selling a product sets the minimum level at which a product may be sold. All the firms strive to cover the cost of a product plus a margin of profit above it.
(b) Utility and demand of the product: Utility or satisfaction derived by a consumer from a product and the intensity of his demand sets the upper price limit for a product. The buyer is ready to pay up to a point where utility from the product is at least equal to sacrifice made in terms of money paid for it. Similarly, if the demand is elastic, a small change in the price results in a large change in the quantity demanded; and if the demand of a product is inelastic, the firm is in a better position to set the price.
(c) Extent of competition in the market: The nature and degree of competition in the market also affects the pricing of a product. Competitors’ prices and their anticipated reactions are considered before fixing the price of a product.
(d) Government and legal regulations: The Government intervenes and regulates the price of commodities. It can declare a product as an essential product and regulate its price. Thus, while fixing the price, the government and legal regulations should be taken into consideration.
(e) Pricing objectives: Generally, a firm’s objective to set the price of a product is considered while pricing the product. A firm which aims at maximising profit in the short run tends to fix a price on the higher side, as compared to the price set when the objective is to maximise profit in the long run. Similarly, if the objective is to capture the market share, prices can be set at a level lower than that of its competitors.
(f) Marketing methods used: The marketing methods used such as research activity undertaken, salesmen employed, amount of advertising, product differentiation, packaging, credit facility etc. affect price fixation. If a firm has some unique element of marketing, it gives the firm a competitive freedom in fixing the price of its products.
Or
What is meant by Packaging? Give any four points explaining why packaging is important.
View AnswerAns. The container which carries the product is called package. Packaging is defined as a set of tasks or activities, which is concerned with the design and production of an appropriate container for the product.
The importance of packaging has enhanced because of the following reasons:
(a) Rising standards of health and sanitation: As the people are becoming health conscious they like to buy packed goods. The reason is that the chances of adulteration in such goods are minimised.
(b) Self-service outlets: Now-a-days self service retail shops are becoming very popular, particularly in big cities. Because of this, the role of sales assistants has to gone to packaging.
(c) Innovational opportunity: With the increasing use of packaging more innovational opportunities become available in this area for the researchers.
(d) Product differentiation: Packaging is helpful in creating product differentiation. The colour, material and size of package makes difference in the perception of the buyers about the quality of the product.
(e) Product promotion: Packaging simplifies the work of sales promotion. Packaging material reminds the consumers constantly about the product. In this way, packaging performs the role of a passive salesman. Consequently, it increases sales.
34. “Coordination is not a separate function of management; it is the very essence of managements.” Clarify.
View AnswerAns. Coordination is the essence of management because it is required in all the managerial functions at all the levels and in all the departments. It exists within each function of management. It is the process integrating all activities to achieve common goals. It helps in maintaining harmony among individual efforts towards the accomplishment of organisational objectives. It synchronizes the working of different groups of persons.
Following points highlight the importance of coordination:
(a) Growth in size: With the increase in the size of the organisation, the number of people employed in the organisation also increases for organisational efficiency, it is important to harmonise the individual goals and organisational goals through coordination.
(b) Functional differentiation: Functions of an organisation is divided into department and divisions every department may have its own objectives, polices and way of working. Coordination helps in linking the activities of various departments and harmonises it towards the common goal.
(c) Specialisation: With specialisation, a characteristic of modern organisation, complexities arises as conflict may erupt in the organisation among functional heads. Coordination helps to reconcile the difference in approach, interest or opinion of the specialist.
Or
Explain the following principles of management:
(a) Scalar chain
(b) Subordination of individual interest to general interest
View AnswerAns. (a) Scalar chain: Scalar chain is the formal line of authority and communication from highest to the lowest ranks. Scalar Chain shows the path of flow of authority and communication. In normal course of formal organisation, it should not be violated. For example, the head, A, has two lines of authority under him. If E wants to communicate with J the communication will flow through the route E-D-C-B-A-G-H-I-J.

However, in case of emergency, E can directly contact J through a Gang Plank. However, they need to inform their superiors about it later on. Gang Plank is a shorter route provided so that communication is not delayed.
(b) Subordination of individual interest to general interest: Every organisation is formed with a goal. Every employee in an organisation has some individual interests also. According to this principle, the interest of an organisation should have priority over the interests of individual employees. This is because interests of the workers and stakeholders are more important than the individual interest of any one person. A manager can ensure this by his exemplary behaviour. He should not misuse his power for his individual interests but use it for the larger general interest. This will raise his stature in the eyes of workers and ensure same behaviour by them.